Cross-cutting and portfolio roles

Commissioning Agent / Retro-Commissioning Provider

Also posted as Commissioning Authority (CxA), Commissioning Provider (CxP), Retro-Commissioning Agent, Existing Building Commissioning Lead, MBCx Engineer, Monitoring-Based Commissioning Analyst

See it in the graph

Verifies that building systems perform together as the owner's requirements specify: writes the Cx plan and functional tests for new buildings, retro-commissions existing buildings that were never commissioned, and runs ongoing/monitoring-based commissioning using BAS data and FDD. Under NYC LL97, a retro-commissioning agent can certify some compliance work.

What they do

  • Prepare commissioning specification and plan; develop functional performance tests
  • Review submittals, O&M documentation and sequences of operation
  • Direct and document tests; verify fixes through retesting
  • Retro-commission existing systems; identify operational fixes
  • Run monitoring-based commissioning on BAS trend data and FDD

What they measure

  • deficiencies found and corrected
  • energy saved
  • tests passed on retest
  • systems covered by MBCx
  • RCx savings persistence (%)

Systems they use

  • BAS trend logs
  • FDD platforms
  • functional test tools
  • energy meters

Certifications

  • BCxA CCP
  • ASHRAE BCxP
  • AEE CBCP
  • EBCP

Jobs to be done

  • Prove sequences work with trend data · QualityWhen testing a system, I want trend logs aligned to the sequence of operations, so I can prove or disprove performance without staying on site for weeks. ReportChecklist
  • Keep commissioning going after handover · EnergyWhen a building drifts after occupancy, I want FDD rules watching the same tests continuously, so I can catch regressions and feed work orders. AlertsBoardWorkflow
  • Document ll97 retro cx · ComplianceWhen a covered building needs compliance, I want retro-commissioning findings and fixes documented per system, so I can certify the report. ChecklistReport

Pain points

  • The commissioning provider typically does not perform hands-on testing; contractors do, so evidence must come from data. (heard in Wikipedia: Building commissioning)
  • An LBNL evaluation of SMUD's retrocommissioning program found only 59% of recommended measures implemented, and whole-building electricity savings fell from about 10.5% in the second post-RCx year to about 8% in the fourth, so findings decay unless tracked. (heard in An Evaluation of Savings and Measure Persistence from Retrocommissioning of Large Commercial Buildings (LBNL, 2004))
  • An ASHRAE Journal study (Dec 2019) of 28 ComEd RCx sites and 167 measures found about 61% of weighted electric savings persisted (76% for the 2010/11 cohort, 49% for 2013/14), because once the consultant leaves, operators and controls techs alter or disable measures in response to comfort complaints, maintenance and retrofits; thermostat settings, optimum start and lighting controls showed zero persistence in small samples. (heard in Persistence in Energy Savings From Retro-Commissioning Measures (ASHRAE Journal, December 2019, via Slipstream))
  • The same study could often not verify measures from BAS trends (many systems lacked long-term trending), had to read control logic or set up new trends and come back, and could not functionally test in occupied buildings or critical hospital and lab zones; recruiting sites was hard because of staff turnover and management changes (28 of 80 audited). (heard in Persistence in Energy Savings From Retro-Commissioning Measures (ASHRAE Journal, December 2019, via Slipstream))

Sources

More roles in cross-cutting and portfolio roles

Every kind of facility

Every job category

See it in the graphAll of PersonaDBBuild an app for this role with Rivet

From PersonaDB, Mapped’s directory of who works in a facility and what they’re trying to get done. Every sourced entry links to the page it came from. PersonaDB’s words are free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with credit to Mapped; the pages it cites keep their own terms. Cite as: “Commissioning Agent / Retro-Commissioning Provider”, PersonaDB, Mapped, https://rivet.mapped.com/personas/role/cross-cutting/commissioning-agent-retro-cx